I bought this case for my 6s plus bc I don't like bulky, tacky, plastic, "loud" cases (it's already big and didn't want to increase the size..said no man ever). I'd prefer not to use a case bc it's like putting a tarp over a beautiful work of art. The leather case is thin, sleek, and tasteful. After a year and a half, here are the pros/cons in my "case". ��

Color: I bought the dark navy a year and a half ago (it looks black so I'm sure the leather wears the same). It darkened as leather does, but since it is dark, I don't have the same complaints as those who bought red or some other lighter color (they look dirty quickly). It may have gotten scratch marks initially (I don't recall it being a problem), but the oils in my hands have richened it over time such that I can't make a scratch mark if I tried. So, dark is best in my opinion.

Quality: The leather began peeling away somewhat at the corners after less than a year of use. The corners are now worn down especially at the bottom. At about a year, one bottom corner began to crack and separate as if you could pull the corner back. Now both bottom corners have broken in this way to where one bottom corner is about to completely detach due to catching on things like clothes. Besides being sightly, it's annoying and damaging. Which brings me to protection.

Protection: I should replace the case bc it's looking a little janky and snagging clothes, but I refuse to remove it until I find equal or better quality. I'm gentle on everything and the leather has a pretty good grip, but it has offered great protection when I'm clumsy or my drinking problem kicks in. Not a scratch!

I've always used speck cases prior, and the leather case lasted longer. I've also broken my screen with a speck case, many times. I'm shocked that this thin, leather case has protected my phone so well. Bottom line, if you plan on replacing your case after a year, and don't mind the cost, go dark.

Source: www.apple.com